Difference Between VDI and DaaS - V2 Cloud

Difference Between VDI and DaaS


Difference between VDI and DaaS

July 27, 2023
08 mins 48 seconds

Author: Haziqa Sajid

Today, cloud computing is the norm in the modern corporate world. The desktop virtualization’s market share is projected to reach around $20 Billion by 2027. VDI and DaaS have emerged as prominent cloud solutions. These virtualization solutions are changing how businesses operate in the digital world. 

Knowing the difference between VDI and DaaS is crucial to opt for the right solution. It helps organizations make informed decisions to unleash the potential of virtual desktop solutions. This blog will help you choose between VDI and DaaS solutions. Let’s discuss each approach and find out which suits your needs.

What is VDI?

Virtual Desktop Infrastructure (VDI) delivers virtual desktops to end-users over a network. It involves creating and deploying virtual machines (VMs) on a centralized server. Each VM represents a virtual desktop. End-users then access these virtual desktops via thin clients or remote desktop protocols. The virtualization software that creates and manages VMs is called hypervisor.

*VDI can be deployed on-premises or in a private cloud environment.

What is DaaS?

Desktop as a Service (DaaS) is a cloud-based delivery model. A DaaS provider hosts and manages virtual desktop instances. These virtual desktop instances are pre-configured templates called desktop images. Desktop Images preserves operating systems, applications, and user settings. Instead of maintaining infrastructure, businesses access desktop images via the internet.

The DaaS provider is responsible for this.

  • Managing and providing virtual desktops.
  • Monitoring performance.
  • Maintenance and security.

*DaaS operates entirely in the cloud, from the DaaS provider’s infrastructure.

What is the difference between VDI and DaaS?

A significant difference between VDI and DaaS is: 

  • VDI is a technology for creating and managing virtual desktops on a central server (on-premise or cloud). It is based on the single-tenant model. It means resources dedicated to only one organization/user.
  • DaaS is a cloud-based server that allows access to virtual desktops and apps. It is developed with multi-tenant models. Shared and managed resources are hosted on the cloud and distributed to client organizations

Let’s discuss the crucial differences between both solutions.

1. Infrastructure Control and Management.

One crucial difference lies in infrastructure ownership of VDI and DaaS. With VDI, organizations own and maintain the underlying infrastructure. This ownership grants them extensive control over the following factors.

  • Customization of infrastructure and resources.
  • Security and Backup.
  • Maintenance and updates.
  • Data management.

The in-house IT teams provide dedicated support to tailor the virtual desktop experience for users. Also, in-house teams manage software updates & patches and ensure infrastructure & data security.

In contrast, DaaS eliminates the burden of infrastructure management. DaaS provider handles all the key responsibilities. 

The in-house IT teams have limited visibility into DaaS deployment compared to VDI. The client organization relies on the DaaS provider’s capabilities. Moreover, DaaS shifts the burden of security and updates to the DaaS provider. All the critical responsibilities fall under the DaaS provider domain.

Simply, VDI empowers organizations with greater customization and controls. And DaaS offers a hassle-free solution by shifting management to the DaaS provider.

2. Scalability.

Scalability and flexibility are other vital factors when comparing VDI and DaaS. Regarding scalability, VDI deployments often face challenges. It involves slower deployment and limited storage in an on-premises framework. 

Scaling VDI involves the following resource-extensive stages.

  • Procuring expensive hardware.
  • Configuring and integrating new hardware into existing infrastructure.
  • Managing resource allocation to match fluctuating end-user demands.

These processes can be time-consuming and require careful planning to ensure reliability and optimal performance.

DaaS enables organizations to deploy VMs as the service provider manages the infrastructure quickly. Scaling up or down requires adjusting the subscription plan to fulfill the demand. This flexibility enables businesses to meet varying demands quickly and efficiently. DaaS offers a seamless virtual desktop experience across different devices and endpoints.

DaaS address relatively prolonged deployment and fixed capacity aspects of VDI.

3. Cost Considerations.

VDI involves some major costing factors, including.

  • Infrastructure cost.
  • Licensing cost.
  • Maintenance cost.

Businesses adopting VDI must invest in servers, storage, server, and virtualization software. It results in substantial upfront capital expenditures (CapEx). There are ongoing costs related to licenses, subscriptions, and maintenance. VDI follows a fixed workload model. It means costs remain relatively constant irrespective of resource utilization.

In contrast, DaaS offers reduced upfront investment. Organizations can dodge heavy CapEx by leveraging the cloud service. DaaS enables an accurate budget estimation with predictable subscription-based costs. It enables organizations to scale their virtual environment while controlling cost overruns. With a flexible model, organizations only pay for the resources they are using. This helps in getting better ROI for IT investment.

Comparing long-term vs. short-term pricing helps businesses choose a solution that aligns with their needs.

4. Security and Compliance.

Security and compliance consideration is also critical when comparing VDI and DaaS. VDI offers security integration in a closed network. With VDI, organizations can experience more significant control over security measures. It allows them to implement customized security policies and methodologies. The increased control is particularly helpful in dealing with sensitive business data. 

In VDI, organizations can implement desired security measures, such as.

  • Network segmentation.
  • Access controls.
  • Data encryption.
  • Centralized monitoring, etc.

DaaS also offers robust security measures to address data security concerns. But you must critically choose a DaaS provider that offers robust security measures. These measures include.

  • Regular data backups.
  • Disaster recovery capabilities.
  • SSL encryption for data transmission.
  • No-trust model for access control.
  • Multi-factor authentication (MFA).

Regarding compliance requirements, both VDI and DaaS deployments are bound to address regulatory compliances. VDI and DaaS solutions offered by V2 Cloud offer compliance with GDPR, SOC 2, HIPPA, etc.

VDI vs. DaaS – Which One is Best for Your Business?

VDI and DaaS differ in infrastructure ownership, management responsibilities, and scalability options. When choosing between VDI and DaaS, consider factors such as:

  • Organization size and complexity – Enterprise-grade businesses with high budgets and complex IT procedures find VDI more suitable. It is because of VDI’s greater control and customization options.
  • Infrastructure requirements and scalability – If organizations require complete control over their infrastructure, VDI is the perfect option. DaaS is perfect for businesses looking for a scalable solution without the burden of infrastructure management.
  • Cost considerations – DaaS typically has lower upfront costs and subscription-based pricing, making it cost-effective for SMBs.
  • Security and Compliance Requirements – VDI grants more significant control over infrastructure security posture. Enterprises having skilled IT teams can fully leverage VDIs’ flexible security. DaaS is suitable for SMBs lacking specialized skills to deal with security challenges.

V2 Cloud offers market-leading DaaS and Cloud VDI solutions. Our Cloud VDI solution shares all our DaaS solution’s fundamental security and operational features. It includes resource optimization, disaster recovery, and quick scalability.

Why Choose V2 Cloud’s VDI & DaaS solutions in 2023?

Choosing the right virtual desktop solution is essential for organizations to meet their needs. V2 Cloud is the market-leading provider, offering customized VDI and DaaS solutions. Moreover, V2 Cloud ensures seamless scalability and robust disaster recovery in its cloud offerings. You can trust your data with V2 Cloud’s daily data backup routine with 7-day retention. 

V2 Cloud has invested heavily in securing its cloud infrastructure, offering industry-standard security protocols and technologies. V2 Cloud’s top-notch security and compliance eliminate data security concerns.

V2 Cloud’s geographically isolated servers are secured with SSL and robust cloud security measures. Our cost-effective pricing makes the cloud transition easier for SMBs and those in the process of forming an LLC. V2 Cloud’s user-friendly dashboard helps you easily monitor the infrastructure’s health. Moreover, our 99.95% uptime keeps your business up and moving. Explore V2 Cloud today and choose smartly for your organization’s virtual desktop needs.

You might also like...

Back to top

Let us help you find the solution that fits your business needs